The Problem with Rails Plugins

The other day Mark asked if I was using active_scaffold. The answer is that I have a perfect use for it, and I installed it, and it works perfectly for what I need it for. However, it also overrides some core Rails functions, and when I execute functionality in my portion of the app the active_scaffold version of those functions are throwing exceptions. For example:

class ActionController::Routing::RouteSet 
  def generate_with_nil_id_awareness(*args) 
    args[0].delete(:id) if args[0][:id].nil? 
    generate_without_nil_id_awareness(*args) 
  end 
  alias_method_chain :generate, :nil_id_awareness 
end

Now, to me, ActionController::Routing::RouteSet seems like a pretty core function in Rails. Of course, it may be the case that I’ve done something wrong and their updated version is catching that error. (You can read more on that here: http://groups.google.com/group/activescaffold/browse_thread/thread/1c4e2f30e8b00ac6/309665c0a85d65c8).

However, my thinking is that I don’t need some plugin f’ing with my app. In fact, this points to a major issue with plugins…they’re not these self-contained units, i.e. components...but, rather, they are mixed in with the core Rails framework and our apps. This means we must think very carefully about which plugins we’ll use because, effectively, we need to know them as well as we know our own code. In other words, they are not black boxes...they are just code we import into our app that somebody else wrote (and is kind enough to share). For example, active_scaffold installs 138 files, and who knows how many kLOCs of code, and who knows what funky stuff they’ve done.

So, long story short, I’m not using active_scaffold because I don’t trust that there isn't come code in there that's gonna mess up my app, and it's too much code for me to review and become familiar with. Any ideas on an alternative?

I’ve looked at Streamlined, Hobo Scaffolding Extensions. According to the docs, Streamlined doesn’t do nested records editing which I require, Scaffolding Extensions handles nested record editing, but isn't the best UX, and Hobo has the same problem as Radiant CMS...I have to put my app into theirs, not their app into mine. (However, both Radiant and Hobo seem like nice platforms for the right project, just not the one I'm currently working on.)